Trucking Workforce: The Pros and Cons of 1099 Contractors vs. Employees

The transportation industry runs on efficiency. For many, the 1099 independent contractor model is the perfect solution for trucking companies. You skip payroll taxes, don’t have to provide benefits, and you potentially gain greater flexibility in staffing.

However, recent regulatory changes regarding worker classification, hidden liability risks, and increased scrutiny from watchdogs like the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Department of Labor (DOL) complicate the independent contractor choice. Does the 1099 model deliver on its promises, or is it a risky shortcut?

Why choose 1099 independent contractors for your trucking business?

Despite some risks, hiring independent contractors has real appeal. There are undeniable advantages to using them for your trucking business:

• Cost savings: Payroll taxes and benefits are significant expenses. Replacing employees with contractors can lead to immediate and ongoing cost reductions in those expenses.
• Scalability: Hiring and firing contractors is often easier, allowing companies to scale their workforce quickly based on business conditions and needs.
• Specialized skills: Certain specialized tasks might not require a full-time employee. Contractors offer a way to access niche skill sets without the commitment of a permanent position.

Why choose employees for your trucking business?

While the 1099 model offers certain advantages, many businesses find opt for an employee model, finding it provides better overall stability and control. Here are some key reasons why:

• Control and consistency: Employees work under the direct supervision of the company. This allows for more oversight, ensuring alignment with company goals and consistent service quality.
• Training and investment: Businesses can invest in employee training and development, leading to a more skilled and dedicated workforce.
• Loyalty and morale: Employees are more likely to feel a sense of belonging and loyalty, boosting morale, productivity, and reducing turnover.
• Brand protection: Workers are representatives of a business and employees are more likely to act ethically and in alignment with company values. This reduces risk and safeguards brand reputation.
• Regulatory compliance: The employee model generally reduces the risk of regulatory violations or misclassification fines.

Hidden costs of using 1099 independent contractors

While the allure of immediate cost savings with 1099 contractors is strong, consider the potential long-term costs lurking beneath the surface:

• Liability risks: Accidents, injuries, or property damage caused by 1099 workers can lead to costly lawsuits against the company, especially if the contractor isn't sufficiently insured. Some states require the worker to have their own insurance for the job, others require the business to provide it. Look into what your state’s regulations are.
• Reputational damage: Incidents involving 1099 contractors can harm a business's reputation, impacting customer trust and future business opportunities.
• Decreased workforce stability: High turnover and lack of loyalty among 1099 contractors can hinder productivity and customer service consistency.

The cost of misclassifying independent contractors

In addition to these risks, anyone leading a trucking company must be aware of employment regulations. The legal landscape surrounding 1099 workers is in constant flux. Regulatory bodies are hyper focused on the issue. The FTC targets deceptive or unfair business practices that may lead to misclassification, while the DOL enforces the laws that ensure the rights and benefits of employees. If you’re caught misclassifying employees as independent contractors, you could face hefty fines and brand damage.

To understand whether you should be classifying a worker as an employee or an independent contractor, use the ABC Test. The ABC test looks at three interdependent factors to make the determination and is being used in more states. It asks the following questions:

• Does the hiring entity control how the work is performed and the details of how tasks are completed?
• Is the work being done part of the hiring entity's usual business activities?
• Does the worker typically operate independently in their field, or do they usually work as an employee in similar roles?

If the answer is “yes” to all three questions, a worker generally should be classified as an employee. If the answer to one or more questions is “no,” they're often able to be considered an independent contractor. To avoid fines and investigations, stay up-to-date and ensure you’re classifying workers correctly.

Risk management and insurance considerations for companies using an independent contractor model

Even a single incident can destabilize a small or medium-sized transportation company. If you opt for 1099 contractors, implementing robust risk management protocols and securing necessary insurance coverage can help avoid and recover from an incident.

You can mitigate risks and minimize losses through:

• Comprehensive insurance coverage: Workers’ compensation and general liability insurance are a base minimum. Work with an expert with experience in trucking and transportation to better tailor coverage to your specific business needs.
• Consult with legal professionals: Stay up to speed on the latest regulations and ensure you’re classifying workers correctly.
• Develop a comprehensive screening process: Vet your contractors thoroughly, checking licenses and safety records.
• Maintain clear communication and control: Define expectations, provide training, and monitor contractor performance to help prevent accidents.

Building a sustainable and responsible workforce requires a proactive approach. Don’t wait for disaster to strike – take action today.

1099 contractor or an employee model? Do what’s right for your transportation business

The 1099 model certainly has its place in commercial trucking, but it's not a magic, one-size-fits-all solution. Carefully evaluate the risks and rewards before committing and take necessary precautions.

While the 1099 model may offer immediate cost reductions, consider the potential long-term costs, such as lawsuits, fines, and damage to your company's reputation. For many businesses, a robust employee model or a hybrid approach might ultimately be more sustainable and secure.

Want to learn more?

Find Brian on LinkedIn.

Connect with the Risk Strategies Transportation team at transportation@risk‐strategies.com.